Forearm crutches · Head-to-head

In-Motion Pro Forearm Crutches vs Thomas Fetterman Black Phantom Carbon Fiber Crutches

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Commissions never change our scores. Details.

Our pick: the In-Motion Pro Forearm Crutches edges it on overall Fit Score (8.4 vs 7.6), winning 3 of 5 categories. The right choice still depends on your priorities, the breakdown is below.

Our pick

In-Motion Pro Forearm Crutches

Millennial Medical

8.4/10 Fit Score

The strongest pick for people on forearm crutches every day. The spring-assist and ergonomic handle target the exact failure points (wrist pain, shoulder fatigue) that make standard crutches miserable long-term.

Visit manufacturer

Thomas Fetterman Black Phantom Carbon Fiber Crutches

Thomas Fetterman

7.6/10 Fit Score

The pick when weight is your top priority. At roughly a pound per crutch, the carbon fiber is noticeably lighter than aluminum, which matters most to people who are on crutches all day, every day. Note the lower 220 lb capacity.

Visit manufacturer

Category-by-category

Category In-Motion Pro Forearm Crutches Thomas Fetterman Black Phantom Carbon Fiber Crutches
Comfort 9/10 9/10
Durability 9/10 8/10
Portability 8/10 9/10
Adjustability 9/10 7/10
Value 7/10 5/10
Overall Fit Score 8.4/10 7.6/10

Specs side by side

SpecIn-Motion Pro Forearm CrutchesThomas Fetterman Black Phantom Carbon Fiber Crutches
MaterialAluminumCarbon fiber
Cuff styleOpen cuff, ergonomic handleLiteStix open cuff
FoldableYesNo
Height range4'2"–6'8" (Short + Tall sizes)Adult, adjustable
Weight capacity350 lb220 lb
Best forLong-term daily useLong-term daily use

Free guide

Still deciding between the two?

Grab our free buyer’s guide, the checklist we use to score every crutch, so you can make the call with confidence.

Before you go

Get our free Forearm Crutch Buyer’s Guide

The 7 things that actually matter when choosing crutches you’ll use every day, plus our current top picks. One email, no spam.